Homeowners ask us this almost every week. The honest answer depends on three things: the condition of the cabinet boxes, whether the layout works for how you cook and live, and your budget.
Refinish if…
- Your cabinets are solid wood, plywood or quality MDF.
- Doors open and close properly and the boxes are square.
- You like your layout and your countertops.
- You want a dramatic change without weeks of demolition.
Replace if…
- Boxes are water-damaged, swollen or delaminating — common under sinks.
- You're moving walls, appliances or plumbing.
- Cabinets are peeling thermofoil that can't be reliably painted.
- You're already replacing countertops and want a completely new layout.
The hidden cost of replacement
New cabinets rarely fit the exact footprint of old ones. That often means new countertops, new backsplash tile, plumbing and electrical adjustments, and weeks without a working kitchen. Refinishing keeps all of that in place.
Our recommendation
Have a professional look at the boxes, especially the sink base. If they're sound, refinishing gives you roughly 80% of the visual impact of a remodel for a fraction of the price. We'll tell you honestly if your cabinets aren't good candidates.
Frequently asked questions
Planning a project? Learn more about our cabinet painting & refinishing services or ask the Paint Pro.
